Why the twin paradox arises the twin paradox arises in the special theory of relativity sr. The earthbound twin remains in a single constant velocity reference frame the entire time while the traveling twin must accelerate to turn around and come. If youre interested in physics, youve probably heard of this paradox, and probably know the solution. The above resolution of the twin paradox is contrary to the spirit of the general theory of relativity. But recently i was thinking about this paradox in general relativity, which turns out to have some fun consequences. Twin paradox, calculating spacetime intervals from both. What is the twin paradox the twin paradox is as old as special relativity. Paradox, arguably the most famous thought experiment in relativity theory. The spacetime diagram analysis this entry borrows heavily from the original faq entry for the twin paradox, by kurt sonnenmoser. Get the knowledge you need in order to pass your classes and more. Although most scenarios in special relativity are most easily described using inertial frames, there is no reason why these frames absolutely must be used. In physics, the twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity involving identical twins, one of whom makes a journey into space in a highspeed rocket and returns home to find that the twin who remained on earth has aged more. But it has also been extensively modified, so he is not responsible for any sloppiness or infelicities. A geometrical view of time dilation and the twin paradox november 12, 2015 90 comments in physics faqs by orodruin based on the amount of questions we receive on the topic at physics forums, there is a lot of confusion in the general public about how time dilation works and the resolution of the twin paradox.
I give the correct resolution of the paradox, explai ning why str is not incon sistent as it app ears at first glanc e. She travels at almost the speed of light to a distant star, while the other twin remains on earth. One is for laymen and the second is for people who think they understand relativity. We study the foundation of spacetime theory in the framework of firstorder logic fol. However, this is just opposite meaning of pure relativity. Absolute frame of reference in the physics community. Imagine that twin a remains at rest on the earth and twin b travels with velocity v 0,8c to the nearest star alpha. The twin paradox is one of those problems that encase within it a beautiful solution or might i say, answer. In this supposed paradox, one of two twins travels at near the speed of light to a distant star and returns to the earth. The twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity, in which the ages of twins are compared after one has made a high speed journey over a long period of. Paranjape, benoit sirois the twin paradox, which evokes from the the idea that two twins may age differently because of their relative motion, has been studied and explained ever since it was first described in 1906, the year after special relativity was invented. The twin paradox several articles that discuss this. Meaning of twin paradox and special relativity theory.
Twin paradox and the logical foundation of relativity theory. Many hundreds of articles have been written about the twin paradox, but all they seem to accomplish is to make the subject even more confusing. The twin paradox and the principle of relativity oyvind gron oslo university college, faculty of engineering, p. The use of the relativistic domain mathematical formulation of the special theory, has enabled this paper to easily show that the twin paradox is in fact not a paradoxical problem at all, as each twin can correctly assess the age difference as a result of the journey of one of them. The twin paradox in special and general relativity. There would be no paradox if not both a and b could consider them self at as rest. At the reunion, both twins agree by inspection that she is older. Perhaps the most famous paradox of this sort is the twin paradox of special relativity. According to the earthling, the returning astronaut.
It also becomes possible to introduce einsteins equivalence principle for treating gravity as acceleration and proving the gravitational time dilation, i. This entry borrows heavily from the original faq entry for the twin paradox, by kurt sonnenmoser. Jan 27, 2017 but this disconnect between the physics of how things really are and the way that we can mentally model the universe can cause apparent paradoxes. In physics, the twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity involving identical twins. Assume that the astronaut has a twin sibling waiting back on earth. Embedded youtube animation, with textual description and a little math. There would be no paradox if not both a and b could consider themselves as at rest. The counterintuitive nature of einsteins ideas makes them difficult to absorb and gives rise to situations that seem unfathomable.
The paradox can be unraveled by special relativity alone. The other twin, earth twin, stays on earth the whole time. Ill post what ive done so far and highlight whats gone wrong for m. The opinion of the world famous scientists on the theory of relativity varied greatly. Correct resolution of the twin paradox michael huem er in the following, i explain the twin paradox, which is supposed to be a paradoxical consequence of the special theory of relativity str. In a recent episode of her series physics girl, dianna cowern gives a simple explanation of the two postulates of special relativity and the twin paradox. Special relativity was one of the first subjects that made me go, wow, thats really how the world works it stretched my imagination, as i hope the twin paradox will yours.
The twin paradox virginia tech department of physics. Such calculations are based only on the special theory, not the general theory. Twin paradox consider the following attributed to paul langevin in 1911. Pdf the twin paradox in the theory of relativity researchgate. The socalled twin paradox is easily resolved by noting that there is a physically meaningful disinction between the experiences of the two twins during the trip. The twin paradox is no paradox according to the law of self.
The majority of them, overwhelmed by mathematical difficulties of the general theory of relativity, decided to keep silent. Pdf the twin paradox is one of the most fascinating paradoxes in physics. The twin paradox is a thought experiment that demonstrates the curious manifestation of time dilation in modern physics, as it was introduced by albert einstein through the theory of relativity. One twin undertakes a long space journey in a spaceship. The wellknown paradox of relativity is described with the addition of information theory. Aug 26, 2016 this video is about the famous twins paradox of special relativity, how time can appear to be faster for two different observers at the same time, and which twin really is older or younger. The twin paradox heres a statement of the twin paradox, designed to make it seem paradoxical. Considering only the time flow difference for each of the twins, the theory of relativity concludes that the twins may have different age, under the conditions of the known gedanken experiment. Because of time dilation, time is running more slowly in the spacecraft as seen by the earthbound twin and the traveling twin will find that the. The twin paradox in the theory of relativity 887 as eartha, who reckoned with constant velocities all the way, neglecting the periods when stella had accelerated motion. The latter experiments, furthermore, have confirmed a gravitational contribution to time dilation, as predicted by the theory of general relativity. The equivalence principle analysis some background.
One twin travels at great distance at the speed of light and returns, much younger than the other twin. Spacetime diagram explanation of the twin paradox the answer to this question is that for the astronaut to return to the earth, heshe must change direction and thereby switch from one inertial frame to another, and that breaks the. The contradiction between these predictions is the twin paradox. An animated introduction to the twin paradox and how it is resolved by either einsteins special theory of relativity or by an application of the general theory of relativity. A geometrical view of time dilation and the twin paradox. One point that might have you puzzled is time dilation. Philosophy and the twin paradox the philosophy forum.
Time, topology and the twin paradox jeanpierre luminet. Pdf the twin paradox in special relativity and in lorentz. The twin paradox is a thought experiment where one twin stays on earth and the other takes a journey through space at incredibly high speeds before returning home. Pdf information relativity theory solves the twin paradox. Here we will approach the concept of special relativity theory thinking the resolution of twin paradox. One of them gets in a spacesh ip and flies around really fast. Einsteins theories and the twin paradox molwickpedia. The twin paradox is the best known thought experiment associated with. The twin paradox several articles that discuss this thought experiment about time how does relativity theory resolve the twin paradox. Kholmetskii department of physics, belarus state university, 4, f. The twin paradox and the principle of relativity i will first consider the usual version of the twin paradox in the minkowski spacetime.
In the following, i explain the twin paradox, which is supposed to be a paradoxical consequence of the special theory of relativity str. This special principle of relativity is, however, not enough to formulate the twin paradox. Relativity trail, free pdf format, with 192 pages, 65 diagrams and 75 illustrations, will provide you with complete detailed algebraic. That theory explains all the experiments that are considered tests of special relativity, and it explains experiments such as the sagnac effect or thought experiments such as the twin paradox in a way that is intuitive, whereas special relativity has to resort to convoluted explanations that leave a feeling of uneasiness and give rise to the. It is pointed out that a complete resolution of the twin paradox demands that the travelling twin takes into account the gravitational effect upon the rate of time when he predicts the ageing of his brother.
Special relativity and the twin paradox physics girl. Mar 30, 2015 in a recent episode of her series physics girl, dianna cowern gives a simple explanation of the two postulates of special relativity and the twin paradox. The twin paradox in special relativity and in lorentz ether theory alexander l. There is no more famous conundrum in special relativity than the twin paradox. Pdf it is pointed out that a complete resolution of the twin paradox demands that the travelling twin takes into account the gravitational effect upon. It is a problem that involves relativistic time dilation, from the special theory of relativity the jargon might seem tough, but the solution is quite intuitive. Theory of time dilation twin paradox and its limitation.
A pair of twins, a and b, synchronize their clocks, and then b moves away usually at a very fast velocity to a distant object, and then returns to a, we find b is younger than a. The famous twin paradox of special relativity involves a scenario where one twin he rockets away from the home twin her, coasts to a faraway turnpoint, reverses course, coasts back, and comes to a halt when they are reunited. Time must never be thought of as preexisting in any sense. Diagrams and equations demonstrating the symmetry of measures and timekeeping differential regarding case 1 and case 2. The earthbound twin remains in a single constant velocity reference frame the entire time while the traveling twin must accelerate to turn around and come home. Nov 12, 2015 a geometrical view of time dilation and the twin paradox november 12, 2015 90 comments in physics faqs by orodruin based on the amount of questions we receive on the topic at physics forums, there is a lot of confusion in the general public about how time dilation works and the resolution of the twin paradox.
Mar 17, 2003 paul daviess recent article how to build a time machine has rekindled interest in the twin paradox, arguably the most famous thought experiment in relativity theory. Mar 30, 2015 how can just two rules of einsteins 1905 theory of special relativity lead to seemingly paradoxical changes in the perception of time. Im want to get a decent understanding of the twin paradox. The twin paradox in special relativity and in lorentz. Correct resolution of the twin paradox michael huemer. A different resolution of the twin paradox thomas e. And within the special theory of relativity the principle of relativity is not valid for accelerated motion. The paradox lies in the question why is the traveling brother younger special relativity tells us. Twin paradox the story is that one of a pair of twins leaves on a high speed space journey during which he travels at a large fraction of the speed of light while the other remains on the earth. The twin paradox and the principle of relativity iopscience.
Embedded youtube animation, with textual description. Theory of time dilation twin paradox and its limitation international journal of advanced research in physical science ijarps page 47 actually, the time we always understand up to these days in perspective of the earth which is based on the rotation of the earth around the sun. Before i can explain why the twin paradox is not considered a paradox, i have to explain why it is considered a paradox. There would be no paradox if only eartha or only stella could consider herself as at rest. One twin remains on earth while the other twin goes on a highvelocity time trip to visit a distant planet. Basically, it states that the faster we go, the more the time is affected. Therefore, it is believed that the general theory of relativity is required to explain the paradox. In special relativity, the paradox arises due to the nonexistence. The clock paradox effect also has been substantiated by experiments comparing the elapsed time of an atomic clock on earth with that of an atomic clock flown in an airplane. The general principle of relativity is essential for the formulation of the twin paradox.
The twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity, in which the ages of twins are compared after one has made a high speed journey over a long period of time, while the other has remained stationary. Come browse our large digital warehouse of free sample essays. Aug 25, 2016 in einsteins theory of relativity, time dilation describes a difference of elapsed time between two events, as measured by observers that are either moving relative to each other, or differently, depending on their proximity to a gravitational mass. Relativity dictates that when he comes back, he is younger than his identical twin brother. Suppose that two identical twins start out on earth, the same age. The twins paradox is the most prominent gedanken experiment that relates the theory of relativity with the arrow of time. About the twin paradox of special relativity theory, there are some resolutions. A simple explanation of special relativity and the twin paradox. Lasky, a lecturer at dartmouth colleges thayer school of engineering, explains. Twin paradox and causality 1 introduction 2 matter of the.
An animated introduction to the twin paradox and how it is resolved by either einsteins special theory of relativity or by an application of the general theory of. Twin paradox and the logical foundation of relativity theory 2 we show that the socalled twin paradox becomes provable in accrel. But these might not be the best fit resolution considering the core concept of special relativity theory. With general relativity, its said that the twin paradox is solved, but this cannot be true, or they are not twins anymore. That is to say, creating privileged frames of reference to distinguish between which twin moves or accelerates more. How does relativity theory resolve the twin paradox. The principle of relativity is essential for the formulation of the twin paradox. Since the foundation of mathematics has been successfully carried through via set theory in fol, it is not entirely impossible to do the same for spacetime theory or relativity. The twin paradox several articles that discuss this thought. Twin paradox in the lorentz ether theory strictly speaking, the title of this section is not correct. Ive very recently started to try to understand special relativity. Lorentz ether theory does not know any paradoxes of relative motion.
Lecture notes relativity physics mit opencourseware. A simple explanation of special relativity and the twin. The twin paradox is an intrinsic contradiction to the relativity of time, which has no solution unless applying general relativity rg. Twin paradox, an apparent anomaly that arises from the treatment of time in germanborn physicist albert einsteins theory of special relativity. The special principle of relativity is, however, not enough to formulate the. Paul langevins socalled twin paradox, based upon albert einsteins special theory of relativity, seems to be by far the most argued topic in physics. In order to have a twin paradox both eartha and stella must. The twin paradox and the principle of relativity arxiv. Of course, this conclusion is based on yet another mistake, since we dont need general relativity to handle accelerations. Since relativistic theories do not really discriminate spatial from temporal coordi nates it is worth making contact with another related and remarquable. Einsteins theories and the twin paradox the twin paradox is insoluble with einsteins special relativity. In einsteins theory of relativity, time dilation describes a difference of elapsed time between two events, as measured by observers that are either moving relative to each other, or differently, depending on their proximity to a gravitational mass.
Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. In the special theory of relativity only nonaccelerated motion is relative. Consider sending an astronaut to a distant star in a spaceship at very hight speed. In the special theory of relativity nonaccelerated motion is relative. Time dilation, the twin paradox and all that the michelsonmorely experiment showed that the light moves with the same speed in any inertial reference frame reference framecoordinate system. Theory of time dilation twin paradox and its limitation 14 open access journal of physics v2 14 2018 time cant be travelled with the fastest speed ever since we know about albert einstein and. This theory predicts that if one of a pair of twins were to fly away from the earth all the way to alpha centauri for instance and then fly back again. Olavs plass, n0 oslo, norway abstract in the standard formulation of the twin paradox an accelerated twin considers himself as at rest and his brother as moving.
1444 1214 221 767 1475 104 1239 1222 1452 7 1240 1430 233 1139 1070 558 185 703 995 954 955 473 1140 1105 696 1212 1087 857 1057 574 534